Jersey Mike’s Menu Prices + Cheapest Menu Hacks (2023)

Jersey Mike’s started as a small sandwich shop called Mike’s Submarines in 1956. A part-time employee named Peter Cancro eventually bought Mike’s Submarines in 1971 and renamed it Jersey Mike’s. The rest they say is history as the sub shop has grown to more than 2,000 locations.

Here are the Jersey Mike’s menu prices in 2023. I also share my favorite ways to save money using coupons, joining the rewards program, and making little-known menu hacks when you order.

Jersey Mike’s Menu

Jersey Mike’s Subs social media.

Cold Subs Menu

Let’s start with the lineup of submarine sandwiches Jersey Mike’s offers.

Hot Sub Menu

Like it hot? Here are some hot sandwich options.

Wraps Menu

In addition to submarine sandwiches, Jersey Mike’s also offers wraps as lighter alternatives.

Chips, Drinks, and Dessert Menu

Catering Menu

How To Build Your Own Jersey Mike’s Sub

You can create our own submarine sandwich at Jersey Mike’s. When you order, just tell the staff what kind of bread, meat, toppings, and sauce you want to put in your sandwich. You go down the sandwich line and be able to specify each step in the sandwich making process. This makes it ideal for customers with dietary restrictions.

I always get The Juice on my sandwich.

Here are some tips for customizing your own delicious Jersey Mike’s sub:

• Select your bread from a variety of options including white bread, wheat bread, gluten-free bread, and more.
• Choose your meat. You can choose turkey, roast beef, ham, salami, chicken, tuna, and turkey.
• Add cheese such as provolone, pepper jack, cheddar, Swiss cheese, and more.
• Add toppings such as lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, banana bell peppers, Jalapeños, cherry pepper relish, and green peppers.
• Select condiments such as mayo, chipotle mayo, honey mustard, Franks Red Hot, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar, salt, pepper, and mustard. Ranch and blue cheese dressing are also available at most locations.

You can leave out some ingredients if you’re on a diet. For example, you can take off the meats and thick sauces if you’re a vegan.

What are the Five Different Sandwich Sizes at Jersey Mikes?

Jersey Mike’s outlets offer five different sandwich sizes. Here they are.

• Mini: This is the smallest sandwich size. This sub is made up of a 4-inch roll and contains 4 to 5 meat slices. Minis are ideal for a quick snack or for people with smaller appetites like kids.
• Regular: A regular sandwich is made of 8 to 10 slices of meat in a 6-inch roll.
• Giant: A giant sub is more than a foot long. The giant submarine sandwich has 16 to 20 slices of meat. It can be shared with two people.
• Wraps: Wraps are sandwich ingredients wrapped in a soft tortilla. There are two wrap sizes—regular and giant.
• Sub in a Tub: This is an option for customers who want to skip the bread. The fillings that usually go inside a sub are instead placed in a tub or bowl.

How Big is a Giant Sub at Jersey Mike’s?

New Jersey Mike’s Locations are opening.

A Jersey Mike’s giant sub sandwich is 14 to 15 inches long. The sub is stuffed with 16 to 20 slices of meat. The giant sub is big enough to satisfy the appetites of 3 regular people or 2 very hungry people with massive appetites.

You can customize your Giant sandwich—or any size of sandwich—as well. In fact, Jersey Mike’s encourages made-to-order sandwiches. The staff can always help you when it comes to sizes and recommended combinations based on your preference.

What is the Secret Menu at Jersey Mike’s?

Do you like mayo on your sub?

The secret menu is a set of menu items or combinations that are not normally published or ordered in Jersey Mike’s. However, they do exist and you can enjoy them. Here are some of the secret Jersey Mike menu items that you might want to check out and how to order them.

• Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo
  Order a #56 (Big Kahuna Cheese Steak) combined with a #43 (Chipotle Cheese Steak).
• R & R Special
  Ask the staff for an R & R Special
• The Chicka-Fila-Roni
  Order a #17 (Mike’s Famous Philly) with pepperoni and chicken.
• The Meateor
  Order this sandwich by its name.
• Surf ‘n’ Turf
  Ask for a #9 (Club Supreme) with Swiss cheese. Get rid of the bacon and substitute the turkey with tuna.
• The Martian
  Order a #5 (The Super Sub). Have the staff substitute the ham with salami. Do the same with the prosciutto; substitute it with pepperoni. Finally, add some provolone.
• Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub
  Ask the staff for a Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub.
• Pepperoni Pizza Sub
  Order a #3 (Ham and Provolone). Add red sauce to the bottom slice of bread. Substitute the Swiss cheese with provolone. Swap the ham with pepperoni. Have the entire sub heated.
• Sweet Pepper Wrap
  Order a Grilled Veggie Wrap. Ask the staff to add cherry pepper relish and chipotle mayo. Substitute the regular bell peppers for a combination of hot peppers and grilled bell peppers.
• Lumberjack Salad
  Ask for a #9 (Club Supreme) in a tub. Substitute the turkey with prosciutto. Drizzle some spicy mustard.

What is “Mike’s Way” at Jersey Mike’s?

You might have heard of a certain “Mike’s Way” from fans of Jersey Mike’s. If you tell the staff you want the sandwich to be prepared “Mike’s Way,” they will prepare your sandwich with the following ingredients and in this order:

• Onions
• Lettuce
• Tomatoes
• Red Wine Vinegar
• Olive Oil
• Spices
• The meat and cheese of your preference

The trademark combination of red wine vinegar, olive oil and Italian spices is referred to as “the juice” by the sandwich chain. You can also ask for “the juice” on the side if you want more control.

Related Reading: Culver’s Menu with Prices: Why So Expensive?

The sandwich starts with onions being placed on the bread first. This is followed by lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil, and spices. Finally, the meat and cheese are placed on top and shoved into the sandwich.

I put a little spin on Mike’s Way each time I visit the establishment. I always ask for Mike’s Way with Mayo. This gives you everything listed above, plus mayonnaise. Of course, you can customize sandwiches any way you want. No need to do it “Mike’s Way.” You can do it your way instead.

What is Jersey Mike’s Most Popular Sandwich?

The Original Italian, also known as sandwich #13, is Jersey Mike’s most popular sandwich. The #13 comes with sliced prosciuttini, ham, cappacuolo, salami, and provolone cheese, all topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, spices, red wine vinegar, and olive oil. The masterpiece is served on a freshly baked sub roll. You can ask the staff to add more toppings and condiments if you’d like.

The Original Italian has been a favorite since Jersey Mike’s first opened its first store in 1956. It continues today as a bestseller. But what’s my personal favorite? I’m glad you asked. My go-to order is the #7, a Turkey and Provolone sub. I order Mikes Way with mayo and occasionally add pickles.

Does Jersey Mike’s have a Healthy Sub?

Jersey Mike’s can order healthier alternatives to the standard subs for health buffs and people who have special dietary requirements.

The Turkey and Provolone (#7) sub is a favorite as it is low in calories and fat. Nutritional information for a regular-sized Turkey Breast and Provolone Sub on white bread is as follows:

• Calories: 740
• Total Fat: 30g
• Saturated Fat: 9g
• Trans Fat: 0g
• Cholesterol: 90mg
• Sodium: 2120mg
• Total Carbohydrates: 73g
• Dietary Fiber: 4g
• Sugars: 8g
• Protein: 43g

There are also other options. For example, the Sub in a Tub option allows customers to order any sandwich without the bread. Thus, the sandwich can be served as a salad. Jersey Mike’s also has a range of wraps, using spinach tortillas instead of bread. Jersey Mike’s website has a Nutrition Information section where you can check the nutritional information for all of their menu items.

Does Jersey Mike’s have Gluten-Free Menu Options?

Abraham Lincoln loves Jersey Mike’s.

Jersey Mike’s has gluten-free sandwiches, wraps, and salads. All you need to do is ask the staff for a gluten-free roll or wrap. It will cost a bit more for a gluten-free sandwich: $1.50 more for a regular roll and $3.00 for a giant size roll. Gluten-free bread costs more due to the specialized ingredients, alternative flours, and additional production processes required to create a product that maintains desirable texture without gluten.

Jersey Mike’s has been offering gluten-free rolls since 2017. Gluten-free options are available in regular and giant roll sizes. Unfortunately, there is not a gluten-free mini roll available in Jersey Mike’s at this time.

To make sure there is no cross-kitchen contamination, Jersey Mike’s has teamed up with Udi’s to provide gluten-free rolls. The rolls are delivered to Jersey Mike’s locations in plastic bags and are not opened until you place the order. This process helps ensure that your sandwich does not come into contact with gluten.

Does Jersey Mike’s Make Salads?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s make salads. Here are some salad options available at many locations. These salads cost between $9 – $12 depending on your order.

1. The Original Italian Salad: A mix of greens, provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni.
2. The Grilled Chicken Salad: A combination of greens, grilled chicken, and a variety of veggies.
3. The Chef Salad: A blend of greens, ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, and veggies.
4. The Tuna Salad: A mix of greens and Jersey Mike’s famous tuna salad, made with 100% Albacore Tuna.
5. The Garden Salad: A simple mix of greens and veggies, which can be customized with your choice of protein and dressing.

You can also order a Sub in a Tub. These are their sub sandwiches without the bread—essentially a salad version of their sandwiches. Note that nutritional information may vary, depending on the toppings and dressing you selected.

Does Jersey Mike’s Deliver?

Jersey Mike’s delivers orders via various third-party delivery services. These include DoorDash, Grubhub, Uber Eats, and Postmates. Ordering can be done via their website or mobile app. You can pick up your order or have it delivered.

Ordering delivery is easy. Just log in to Jersey Mike’s website or app, input your location, and select the menu items you want to order. Payment can be done online and you can track your order in real time.

Check the delivery options and fees for your location on Jersey Mike’s website. You can do the same through third-party delivery service’s app.

What are the Jersey Mike’s Menu Numbers for Each Sandwich?

Many of the items in Jersey Mike’s menu are indicated in numbers. Here are menu numbers for some of the restaurant’s most popular sandwiches:

• #1 – BLT
• #2 – Jersey Shore’s Favorite (Ham & Cheese)
• #3 – The American Classic (Roast Beef & Provolone)
• #4 – The Original Italian
• #5 – The Super Sub
• #6 – Famous Roast Beef & Provolone
• #7 – Turkey Breast & Provolone
• #8 – Club Sub
• #9 – Club Supreme
• #10 – Tuna Fish
• #11 – The Veggie (Provolone, Swiss, & Green Bell Peppers)
• #12 – Cancro Special (Roast Beef, Provolone, & Pepperoni)
• #13 – The Original Italian (Prosciuttini, Cappacuolo, Ham, Salami, & Provolone)
• #14 – The Veggie (Swiss, Provolone, Avocado, & Cucumbers)
• #15 – Grilled Pastrami Reuben
• #16 – Chicken Philly Cheesesteak
• #17 – Steak Philly Cheesesteak
• #18 – Chicken Parmesan
• #19 – BBQ Beef
• #20 – Grilled Veggie

What Makes Jersey Mike’s Subs Different than Other Sandwich Shops?

Get free delivery every Tuesday when you order through the app in May, 2023.

Many people say that there’s something special about Jersey Mike’s that sets them apart from other sandwich shops. Here are some of the reasons.

• Authenticity: Jersey Mike’s prides itself on its roots in the Jersey Shore, offering an authentic East Coast-style sub experience. The company emphasizes its heritage and adherence to traditional recipes and techniques.
• Freshly Sliced Ingredients: Unlike some other sandwich chains, Jersey Mike’s slices their meats and cheeses fresh for each sandwich, right in front of the customers. This practice ensures the highest quality, freshness, and taste.

Related Reading: McDonald’s Menu Prices + Free Big Mac Coupon 

• The Bread: Jersey Mike’s bread is a distinguishing factor, as they use a proprietary recipe for their white and wheat sub rolls. The bread is baked fresh daily in each store, providing a superior taste and texture compared to some competitors.
• The “Mike’s Way” Tradition: Jersey Mike’s has a specific way of dressing their subs, known as “Mike’s Way,” which includes onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, salt, pepper, and oregano. This combination of toppings and condiments adds a unique and consistent flavor profile to their sandwiches.
• Focus on Philanthropy: Jersey Mike’s is known for its commitment to giving back to the communities where they operate with an emphasis on local charities. Their annual “Day of Giving” event donates 100% of sales from participating locations to local charities. In addition, Jersey Mike’s has been doing a Month of Giving for the past 13 years. In March 2023, the company donated $21 million to 200 different charities.

These factors contribute to the unique taste and experience of enjoying a Jersey Mike’s sub.

How to Save Money at Jersey Mike’s

There are several savvy ways to save money at Jersey Mike’s. The simplest way to join the loyalty program MyMikes. When you sign up, you start generating Shore Points that can be used toward free food. You earn a different number of points depending on the order:

• 3 points for every KID’S MEAL
• 4 points for every MINI size sub or Breakfast Sandwich (where available)
• 6 points for every REGULAR, Wrap or Sub Bowl
• 12 points for every GIANT

Once you accumulate 48 points you earn a free mini size sub. But I always wait until reaching at least 72 points so I get a free regular size sub, sub bowl, or wrap. When you reach 144 points and you get a free giant sub.

To keep things simple, you would need 12 regular subs to earn 72 points to get 1 regular size sub for free. If you purchased 12 Turkey and Provolone (#7) subs for $7.25 each or $87 in total spend. If you redeemed your points for another Turkey and Provolone sandwich you would save 8.3%. If you ordered a higher priced sub like the The Original Italian priced at $8.25, you’d save 9.48%.

Double Points Day is a terrific way to save at Jersey Mike’s.

But the deals don’t end there. All MyMike’s members get a coupon for a free regular sub and a drink on their birthday.

Next, you’ll want to check the Jersey Mike’s social media accounts like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram to find deals. You’ll find announcements about things like Double Shore Points days. These limited-time promotions help you earn twice the number of rewards points for order (up to 144 points max per order). Using an example from April 2023, Jersey Mike’s shared they would offer Double Points every Tuesday during the month after 4 p.m.

Check your local newspaper or coupon mailers as well. You can frequently find coupons for a BOGO regular sandwich offer when you purchase two medium soft drinks. Cut those coupons and save.

Don’t be fooled by the name—Kids Meals cater can be an affordable way to eat at Jersey Mike’s no matter what your age is. For just $4.95, you get a 4-inch kids’ sub (your choice of ham and cheese or turkey and cheese), a side of chips or small cookie, and a 12-oz fountain drink. If you’re not too hungry this a smart way to dine for less than $5.

Finally, are you hungry for a new job opportunity? I’ve saved the best savings opportunity for last. Every Jersey Mike’s employee gets a free meal and drink during each shift. Even while you’re off the clock, you’ll get 50% off any order as an employee. This is a delicious way to earn some additional cash.

Are there Menu Hacks at Jersey Mike’s?

There are several menu hacks you can try at Jersey Mike’s to make your Jersey Mike’s experience even better.

• When ordering a sandwich, ask for it to come “Mike’s Way.” This is the chain’s signature way of making a submarine sandwich. This is a perfect way of ordering if it’s your first time visiting a Jersey’s Mike’s outlet and you’re not sure what to order.
• Customize your sandwiches. Jersey Mike’s allows customers to tailor their orders according to their tastes and preferences. Just tell the staff how you want your sandwich.
• Consider adding a few extra toppings to your sandwich to give it more flavor and texture. Some suggested toppings include pickles, jalapenos, and banana peppers.
• Order the Sub in a Tub. This is great if you’re on the lookout for low-carb or gluten-free food.
• Combine sandwiches into one. For instance, order a “Turkey and Roast Beef” sandwich. This combines both Turkey Breast and Roast Beef subs.
• Save money by ordering a mini-sub; it’s usually enough for a single person. If there are 3 or 4 of you, order a giant and share it among yourselves.

By using these menu hacks, you can maximize your experience and your budget when enjoying a meal at Jersey Mike’s.

With headquarters in Manasquan, New Jersey, Jersey Mike’s has over 2,000 locations. There are even two locations in Ontario, Canada, and one in Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico. Founder of the chain, Peter Cancro, started franchising Jersey Mike’s in 1987. This business decision helped kick off multi-decade growth for the sandwich chain.